Home Contact | Advertising Subscribe Museum of Anthropology at the University of British Columbia
Search Listings
Alberta British Columbia Oregon Washington
Exhibition Previews
Calendar
Gallery Websites
Conservation Corner

SEARCH EDITORIAL
To find gallery listings use search at page top right.

CURRENT COLUMN

Why Paper Discolours (Part 2)
Why Paper Discolours (Part 2)

Why Paper Discolours (Part 1)
Why Paper Discolours (Part 1)

Mending a Tear in an Aboriginal Drum
Mending a Tear in an Aboriginal Drum

Distortions and Dimensional Changes
in Paper (Part 3)
Distortions and Dimensional Changes
in Paper (Part 3)


Distortions and Dimensional Changes
in Paper (Part 2)


Distortions and Dimensional Changes
in Paper (Part 1)

After treatment
Oscar Cahén: Innovative Conservation
for an Innovative Artist

Structural
Rigid Water Gels: New Treatment Options for Paper Conservators

Structural
Structural Remedies for Canvas Paintings

Digital
Organizing and Preserving Collections - Part 4: Digital-based Material

Photos
Organizing and Preserving Collections - Part 3: Photo-based Material

Organizing and Preserving Collections - Part 2: Paper-based Material

First Steps
Organizing and Preserving Collections - Part 1: The First Steps

Natural Dyes
The Use of Natural Dyes in Textile Conservation

Butterfly
A Relocation Project

Challenges of Preserving Contemporary Artwork

Preserve Your Investment through Art Conservation

A Project Completed: Heritage Preserved

Old and New Methods for Cleaning Paintings

I Can See Clearly Now – Or Can I? Part 2

I Can See Clearly Now – Or Can I?

The E.J. Hughes Mural: An Expanded Project

Is She or Is She Not an Emily

Treating Art with Sensitive Media

Malaspina Mural: An Update

For the Artist: Testing Your Materials

Conservator as Art Historian

Alum Sizing and the Art of W.J. Phillips

Treatment of an Elizabeth Keith Wood Block Print

Structural Treatment of an Emily Carr

The Treatment of a Monumental Wall Hanging

Changing Images

Preserving a Rare Record

Gold Leaf: Imitation and Genuine

The Case Against Canvas Backings

Heritage Colours: Research Discovers Original Colours

Lighting Your Art: Balancing Seeing and Protecting

The Double-Sided Emily Carr Painting

Choosing a Period Picture Frame

How to Identify a Picture Frame

Stretching Canvas and Restretching Artwork

Mounting Textiles

Aging Paintings:
Some Causes and Effects

Chine Collé Prints

What's Your Favourite Color?

Backing Removals

Rips, Holes and Tears

Filling in the Gaps

DIY – Preventative Care of Paintings

Frame it Right

Fire, Water and Smoke-Damaged Paintings

Inherent Vice

Saturated Problems:
A Water-Damaged Painting

Moldy Paper

Conserving Time

Conserving Paper: Dos and Don'ts

Repair of Textiles

Conserving Wood

Rescuing Endangered Murals

Repairing Acid-Matte Burn

Art Services & Materials
Exhibition Openings & Events


Conservation Corner Back

Alum sizing and the art of W.J. Phillips

by Rebecca Pavitt
www.fineartconserve.com

This watercolour titled Docks, Alert Bay came to me in very sad condition, covered with a mottled dark brown discoloration. This type of damage is quite typical of certain alum-sized papers and is also commonly found on the margins of Phillip’s woodblock prints. The question explored in this article is “Why?”

Docks, Alert Bay before treatment

Before treatment

Docks, Alert Bay after treatment

After treatment

Alum has been used as an ingredient in paper sizing for at least five hundred years in Europe, and even longer in the Orient. Very early on, papermakers discovered that adding alum to traditional gelatin sizing reduced problems with mold (alum is a biocide) and increased the finished paper’s resistance to abrasion and water.

The latter quality is especially important for the watercolour artist. Without sufficient sizing, washes cannot flow over the paper, but sink directly into the sheet, and the slightest reworking will rough up and mar a soft-sized paper’s surface. Watercolour papers are made with these special needs in mind, but it was well-known by artists that soft-sized papers not made for painting could be brushed with additional coats of alum-water to improve their working properties.

Phillips was very interested in the technical aspects of his profession and would almost certainly have been familiar with the practice of sizing papers with alum. He was also introduced to the Japanese tradition of sizing woodblock printing papers with dosa – alum and gelatin solution – by the printer Yoshijiro Urushibara and he describes the method in detail in his book, The Technique of the Color Woodblock, published in 1926.

Docks was probably painted in 1927, when Phillips visited his sister in Alert Bay, with alum sizing fresh in his mind. It seems likely that Phillips alum-sized the paper to prevent rippling or uneven paint distribution, but why did the sizing undergo such extreme discoloration? One possibility is that these darker than normal discolorations are caused by the particular type of alum used.

True alum, aluminium potassium sulfate, was largely replaced by the much cheaper (and highly acidic) aluminum sulphate or papermakers alum over the course of the 19th century. True alum can be highly refined and purified, removing contaminants such as iron. Papermakers alum cannot be purified to the same extent, and is often contaminated with iron and sulfuric acid, both highly detrimental to the health of paper.

My guess is that artists like Phillips and some Japanese woodblock printers were working at the end of that change-over, and substituted papermakers alum for true alum, not realizing the difference it would make.

Fortunately, it was possible in this case to safely remove most of the discolouration with chelating agents and a mild bleaching solution and with thorough rinsing by float washing and locally applied water mist on a suction table.

Previously: Treatment of an Elizabeth Keith wood block print
Next Issue: Conservator as art historian

 Tue, Sep 4, 2007